A conversation is any social scenes where two or more characters are talking and attempting to achieve their goals through dialogue, such as by negotiating, deceiving, interrogating, or establishing personal connections.
When you try to convince, intimidate, lie to, or otherwise influence someone, you typically need a skill test to succeed. Even then, particularly confident or stubborn characters might resist your successful attempts to influence them, and you’ll have to strategically wear them down to get what you want out of the conversation.
Setting the Scene
Any type of scene can transition into a conversation when it fits the story. In fact, conversations can often pop up during another scene, whether that’s a tense negotiation during a pause in combat or a chance encounter during an endeavor. The GM doesn’t need to officially announce “you’re in a conversation now,” but they will usually set the scene to let you know who you’re engaging with and what to expect.
The GM will briefly describe who you’re talking to and might ask what you want to achieve (if it isn’t obvious). Based on this objective and how you have approached the situation, the GM will give you a sense of the other characters’ dispositions and tell you who might need to be convinced—and of what.
Objectives
Social interaction is messy, so it’s not always clear what people want or prefer. It can help the flow of a scene for the GM to provide clear objectives, but there isn’t a right or wrong way to go about achieving these objectives, so the GM can’t give you a checklist of what to do. However, they should provide helpful context on the other participants’ motives, needs, and desires (or at least, those you’d be aware of). This allows you to make relevant contributions to the conversation.
Order of Conversations
Conversations in the game unfold much like those in real life, as characters pontificate, interject, argue, and talk over each other. To reflect this free-form interaction, conversations have significantly less structure than combat, and time isn’t tracked as concretely. However, certain rules help the GM adjudicate the flow of the conversation and determine how your attempts go over with NPCs in the scene.
Flexible Rounds
While you’ll find yourself in many conversations that are less than polite, it’s important that out of character, everyone still has fun and feels involved. Characters generally contribute one at a time, and everyone in the scene should have a chance to participate (if they want to). When every character in the scene has had an opportunity to contribute, this counts as one “round” of the conversation. This isn’t as structured as a round of combat, but it helps with timing your abilities and other game effects.
Just because each character gets a chance to participate, it doesn’t mean they always will. Some characters might prefer to hang back and let others do most of the talking. But it’s a good idea for the GM to check back in with each player if their character hasn’t weighed in recently. If a character’s last contribution was to lean stoically against the back wall while others do the talking, the group should check if that’s what the player wants to continue doing.
Contributions
As you, your fellow players, and the GM play out your interactions, you can communicate either by using your character’s voice or describing your actions in the third person. Either way, each time you meaningfully influence the conversation, you’re making a contribution. For example, you might shift the conversation’s focus, sway participants, support an ally, or gain more insight into the situation. These contributions aren’t intended as rules to limit the scene, but to provide as much support for roleplay as your group finds helpful.
Contribution Outcomes
How a given contribution is resolved depends on what you’re attempting to accomplish. Some contributions just include a wry quip or flavorful interjection, while others have a significant impact on the conversation (and might require a skill test to resolve).
Most contributions work toward one of these five outcomes:
Influence a Person. Many contributions attempt to influence another person through lies, logic, intimidation, or other means. To change a character’s opinion or behavior, you’ll generally make a skill test with a DC equal to their Spiritual or Cognitive defense (depending on the skill used). Even on a successful test, the other character might resist your influence by spending focus (see the upcoming “Focus in Conversations” section).
Help or Hinder Efforts. Conversation can be a group effort, so you might help by augmenting an ally’s arguments or undercutting an opponent’s position. This contribution usually grants your ally an advantage—or your opponent a disadvantage—on their next test in the conversation.
Bolster an Ally. You can encourage, reassure, or otherwise bolster another person in the conversation. This usually results in your target recovering a bit of focus (determined by the GM).
Gather Information. You can scrutinize another person or the environment. The GM might ask you to make a skill test against your target’s Spiritual or Cognitive defense (depending on the skill used).
Interject Flavor. You can always interject to add flavor or context to a conversation. These contributions have no rules—they’re just part of the fun of roleplaying!
Who Can You Influence?
To influence someone, you must be able to communicate with them, which generally requires them to sense or otherwise receive information from you. Sometimes, influence requires complex arguments, while other times, a look or gesture is enough to get the point across.
If an ability affects a character you “can influence,” it refers to anyone you can communicate with effectively.
Tests in Conversations
Nearly any skill can be used in a conversation at the GM’s discretion. The Contribution Test Examples table suggests some contributions that might require a test.
| Skill | Usage |
|---|---|
| Deception | Lying to convince someone of an untrue premise. |
| Deduction | Logically analyzing an argument to find flaws. |
| Insight | Using empathy to understand someone else’s position. |
| Intimidation | Browbeating someone to weaken their position. |
| Leadership | Inspiring someone to follow their better nature. |
| Perception | Observing someone to notice whether they take any suspicious actions. |
| Persuasion | Using raw charm to convince someone to act against their better judgment. |
The Conversation Opportunities and Complications table provides inspiration for tests that result in either of those.
| Opportunity | Complication |
|---|---|
| You remember a helpful and relevant fact. | Something you thought you knew turns out to be a lie. |
| An observer is impressed with you. | An observer is scornful of you. |
| You distract others from noticing the intentions behind your actions. | You draw unwanted attention to yourself in the conversation. |
Abilities in Conversations
Talents apply in circumstances beyond combat! Talents and other abilities that specify an action or reaction can be used in conversation, usually as your contribution. Most special activations can be used too, at the GM’s discretion.
Free actions can be used at any time, and never take your contribution. Though some abilities might be disruptive to a conversation, and depending on the reactions of other characters in the scene, could derail the conversation entirely!
Focus in Conversations
Your focus represents your mental wherewithal, concentration, and patience, making it very important during conversations. Until you run out of focus, you can use it to avoid being influenced by other characters and to fuel special abilities granted to you by talents.
Resisting Influence
Both NPCs and PCs tend to have a strong idea of who they are, and of what they will or won’t do. So, when you attempt to influence someone in a conversation, it’s unlikely you can change their mind with a single skill test.
When a character succeeds on a socially oriented skill test against an opponent (or otherwise does something very persuasive), their opponent can choose to spend focus to resist influence. The amount of focus spent depends on how persuasive the GM decides the contribution is. If reasonably persuasive, an opponent must spend 2 focus to remain resolute. If an argument is extremely strong, the opponent must spend 4 focus.
If the GM decides a particular argument is incredibly persuasive or hits on a topic an NPC is unlikely to resist, the NPC might choose to not resist at all. Otherwise, once the NPC runs out of focus, they generally concede the point or become open to a compromise (see “Running Out of Focus”).
Resisting Mechanical Effects
Any effect targeting a “character you can influence” can be resisted by that character by spending 2 focus, as if the effect were a socially oriented skill test. Other effects cannot be resisted unless specifically stated (or decided by the GM).
Player Characters and Influence
In conversations, your opponents are usually the ones resisting influence, not you. Depending on how the conversation goes, the GM might ask you to resist influence at some point—but the way you roleplay these situations is up to you (see Player Characters with No Focus).
Running Out of Focus
An NPC’s focus can be an effective timer or gauge for your progress in a conversation. Whereas a pliable target like a town guard might give into your party’s persuasion quickly, a strong-willed NPC requires more convincing. For these characters, the GM can have them spend focus to resist the PCs’ influence, requiring the group to wear down the NPC with a few successful attempts.
When an NPC is reduced to 0 focus (often because of resisting influence), they become too frustrated, scattered, or distracted to effectively contribute to a conversation. They can no longer resist being influenced and might check out of the conversation entirely.
Player Characters with No Focus
If you start running low on focus (and thus narratively become more vulnerable to outside influence), you might decide you want to step away from the conversation—or you might consider a cue to roleplay a different tactic, based on how you think your character would react. A hothead might decide to start a fight, while a more reserved character might decide to give up on conversation and find more accommodating characters to talk to or seek other ways to pursue their goal.
Even when you’re completely out of focus, this never forces your character to do or believe something you disagree with. You can have your character change their mind if you wish, but it’s up to you to decide what the effects are and how this impacts the story.
Resolving Conversations
The GM determines when a conversation resolves based on the narrative flow of the scene. A conversation can end in success in many ways, such as the following:
- A PC makes a contribution that’s so aligned with an NPC's goals that it doesn’t require a skill test.
- A PC succeeds on a test that appeals to an NPC's core values, and the NPC chooses not to resist influence.
- A PC succeeds on a test, and the NPC has no focus (or chooses not to spend focus) to resist.
- The party otherwise achieves their objective, such as by learning important new information.
A conversation typically fails when the progressing narrative prevents the original goal from being achievable in way such as the following:
- The party fails multiple tests.
- A PC (or allied NPC) acts in a way that provokes an NPC's hostility.
- A PC (or allied NPC) central to the conversation decides to drop out because they don’t have enough focus to spend.
- The party otherwise fails to achieve their narrative objective, such as by accidentally disclosing a dangerous secret.
Conversation Types
Conversations can take many forms based on the participants’ goals. This section suggests tips for running a few types of conversations, but conversations can shift fluidly between these (and many other) types as goals develop and the scene unfolds.
Inquiry
In an Inquiry, one or more parties are trying to acquire information. Inquiries range from casual fact-finding conversations to formal interviews to tense examinations. These typically involve one party trying to acquire information while another tries to withhold or hide it, but there could be multiple inquiring parties with varied motives, such as in a legal proceeding.
When your group starts an Inquiry, the players should discuss what information they’re looking to gain, and the GM should consider what NPCs want to learn.
If it turns out the information can be had for a price, an Inquiry might become a Negotiation.
| Opportunities | Complications |
|---|---|
| Through your questioning, you learn you share an objective (or enemy) with the person you’re questioning. | You accidentally reveal more than intended to the person you’re questioning—or you can spend 2 focus to resist. |
| Careful hints or vague threats unsettle the person you’re questioning. You gain an advantage on your next test against them. | The person you’re questioning sees an opening for their own scheme. You gain a disadvantage on your next test against them. |
| The person you’re questioning sees an opportunity with you, and it puts them at ease. | Someone enters the scene with an unrelated request for the other party. |
Negotiation
In a Negotiation, two or more interested groups are attempting to get something from each other, generally while expending as few resources as possible. Negotiations are a combination of competition and cooperation, with each side trying to levy every advantage at its disposal—without frustrating the other party into simply walking away.
When beginning a Negotiation, the GM and players should discuss what the players want to get from the other party, and the GM should consider what that might cost. If the PCs are trying to secure a material good or service, a price may be available in their setting rulebook. If they want something that’s more abstract, the price might be harder to quantify, but the GM should still start by deciding what the other party’s opening price is (such as a favor, rare piece of equipment, strategic alliance, or commitment to some cause).
If one party stops dealing in good faith (or it’s revealed they never intended to uphold their end of the bargain), a Negotiation might become a Scheme.
| Opportunities | Complications |
|---|---|
| You notice a subtle clue about the resources the other party truly has available. | You tip your hand about the exact resources you possess—or you can spend 2 focus to resist. |
| You convince the other party you have the backing of a powerful patron. | The opposing party grows suspicious, suspecting you might be a spy or informant. |
| The person you’re dealing with inadvertently reveals that someone else could provide what you need. | Another bidder enters the scene; you’re at risk of them increasing the price unless you can drive them off. |
Scheme
In a Scheme, at least one party is trying to dupe another person or organization. This could be a con job to steal material wealth, an intrigue to learn protected knowledge, or a plot to spread a useful rumor that sets up future machinations. Usually, the targeted party— often known as the mark—believes they’re in a different type of conversation. A Scheme is very difficult to pull off once it’s recognized as such. If the deceivers succeed, the mark might not realize they were duped until long after the conversation ends.
If the PCs are scheming against an NPC, the GM should start the scheme by asking how the PCs are presenting the Scheme (what’s their cover story?), as well as their eventual goal. The GM should also ask the players what steps their characters take to make the false premises seem plausible and have them make tests for these preparations accordingly.
If a Scheme is ever unveiled to all parties, the conversation likely ends. The ultimate outcome depends on the circumstances—it might mean a combat, or the would-be marks might simply leave.
| Opportunities | Complications |
|---|---|
| Your mark unknowingly reveals information about themself, giving details you can later use to profit even more. | A neutral NPC reveals themself to be an agent of the opposition. |
| A neutral NPC mistakes you for a figure of authority or a specific trustworthy individual, corroborating your story. | A third party will reveal your scheme unless you can pay them or drive them off. |
| You provide a small sample or preview, putting your mark at ease. | An investigator arrives at the worst possible time. |
Social
During a Social conversation, characters try to form bonds, impress potential allies, and build interpersonal connections. Socializing is generally earnest, though that doesn’t mean that all participants must be wholly truthful. Characters may be pursuing hidden agendas, and rival NPCs may be working to undermine the PCs’ efforts.
When you begin a Social scene, the GM should ask the players if their characters have any specific goals and encourage them to pursue these narratively. Similarly, the GM should consider the narrative goals of the NPCs, so they can proactively pursue these goals during lulls in the conversation.
If one or more groups decide to pursue agendas, socializing can shift into any other conversation type as the GM and players see fit.
| Opportunities | Complications |
|---|---|
| You notice a subtle hint of someone’s hidden emotional state. | You accidentally reveal a detail or make a comment that opens you up to ridicule. |
| You gain the upper hand, recovering 1d4 focus. | You become aggravated or drained by the conversation, losing 1 focus. |
| You impress the person you’re talking to, making them inclined to help you later. | You spot an opportunity to pursue one of your goals, but in a way that would disrupt your current conversation. |
